What Killed Jerry
Carolynn Mireault
Jerry Morbier stroked out in the car on his way to the pharmacy, killing him, while his car kept going on a diagonal, hitting a student driver before coming to a stop in the grass verge in front of a Huck’s Food & Fuel.
They flew his body back home to Pennsylvania from Kentucky, where he’d been living with his wife, her mother, and, strangely, a woman from their church group. Everybody suspected he and this woman had something to do with each other.
Although not named for Morbier cheese, Jerry was composed the same way: clammy and ivory, carrying the mild smell of vegetable dye and ammonia. This I remembered with certainty, along with the golden retriever he had in college, who he shaved down to the pink in the summers. At first, I didn’t know if I should even go to the funeral. I hadn’t seen Jerry in years, but the Facebook group had taken on a life of its own and the event seemed to transform from a funeral to a high school reunion.
We’d gone to school together, then college, where Jerry had taken me on a single date to Pancho’s Mexican Buffet, (long before that location closed, and before meeting his wife, Robyn). He’d sat plainly across from me with his tray, which heaped with Spanish rice, the flauta platter, a plastic cup of pico de gallo, and a bottle of strawberry melon Fruit Works. I was a vegan at the time, folded refried beans into a corn tortilla and consequently shat zinc for three days. He’d asked me twice, “Are you sure that’s all you want?”
Jerry and I didn’t have much in common, and although generally quiet and reserved, he detailed his path to the Lord, which stunned me with its mediocrity; (i.e., minor car wreck on the Jersey Turnpike, great aunt receiving an Alzheimer’s diagnosis). By the end of our meal, I had the impression that he hadn’t been through all that much by my standards; I’m not saying I had, but I also wasn’t claiming a life of tragedy and selling saviors. He had a blue crucifix bumper sticker on the back of his ’93 Ford Taurus, which he boasted matched his astrological sign. In return, I joked that I drove a Toyota Battle-axe, equally reflective of my personality, at which he cocked his head, smiled, and asked, “That a real make and model?”
I wished I’d given him a chance. For all I knew, he was onto something with the stuff about Christ and God. It seemed to make sense to a lot of people; what made me too good for it? I thought there’d be a line of guys behind him. I thought I’d have all these options, but after twenty more years enduring Pennsylvanian bachelors, hearing about Jerry’s path to God at Pancho’s was looking pretty good.
I’d since moved three hours east to Pittsburgh but made the drive back to Yardley for the funeral. The Facebook group was alive with offers to contribute to the funeral costs of flowers and catering. Many of them had moved to the surrounding parts of New Jersey, like Ewing, which perched right across the Delaware River. Others picked life up in Philadelphia, having marriages and kids and cheesesteaks surrounded by all that murder.
Yardley had been an excellent place to grow up, or so my parents said upon moving us there when I was a teenager.
“Don’t you know who William Yardley is?” my father had asked from the back of the moving van while unloading his collection of records, which all turned out to be badly damaged. My mother was intoxicated, tearing through boxes to find sheets, insisting that the beds should be made before anything else got done. They later retired to Naples, Florida, and I didn’t mind seeing them go.
The Facebook group brimmed with familiar names. Among the most notable: Elisa Matthews, a poorly-aged cheerleader who used to smoke during complicated lifts; Lindsey Brett, a skinny, little train wreck who’d undergone four abortions; Jesse Laurent, a guy who used to hook up with me (and sometimes Lindsey Brett) in the back of my father’s Vauxhall Nova; Dustin and Sara Dupont, seemingly the only high school sweethearts who’d survived; April Frank, a smart but somewhat flat Republican bitch with fantastic calves; and Christina Stewart, my childhood best friend who I had not seen since we tried rooming together in college and had a falling out.
Robyn Morbier, Jerry’s widow, administrated the group. In an act of seeming confusion or misplaced self-worship, she had made the banner photo a clipart of a pink breast cancer awareness ribbon, a cancer she herself had survived.
It was rumored that during Robyn’s chemotherapy, the woman from their church group had moved into their house. Supposedly, she had some medical training and needed a place to live. There was talk that it had blossomed into a full-blown affair, in which Jerry found even more God.
It was a perfect day for a funeral: gray sky stuffed up with clouds, air cool enough for a jacket, striking the mood down just below the appropriate equator.
I sat in my car in the lot outside Thompson & White Funeral Home almost forty minutes early, smoking a Newport menthol and chewing gum at the same time. On a date, I had called this a “life hack,” and he had asked if I was kidding, if this was some kind of joke, and I could have said it was, but I’d heard somewhere—read somewhere—that relationships are supposed to be honest. He never called me back. I could have been just another thing along his path to the Lord. I could have put him over the edge with that one.
Someone knocked on my passenger window, startling me. I dropped my cigarette out of the driver’s side and rolled the passenger window down.
“I thought that was you,” she said.
It was Lindsey Brett, AKA four abortions, AKA ate me out in the Vauxhall Nova while Jesse took her from behind.
“Hey, you wanna get in?” I asked.
“I was going to get a coffee or something at Afton’s,” she said. “Wanna come with? We’ve got, like, forty minutes. They’re still setting up.”
Afton Street Grille was just two doors down, marked by a big flag flapping with the coat of arms emblem. The street was beautiful, so Christian-American with a looming stone church, its steeple impaling the low-hanging nebulae. Quaint businesses were run out of brick and white buildings, selling yarn and breakfast and other quaint things.
Lindsey and I didn’t say a thing as we walked, not until we sat down across from each other at a copper bistro table. The chairs were loud on the cherry floor when we scooched them in, a sloping heart design welded into their backrests. We glanced around at the other patrons but saw no one we recognized.
“Are you eating?” I asked.
“I think just coffee,” said Lindsey.
“So, what’s been up with you? Where are you living?”
“Ewing,” she said. “Can you believe it about Jerry?”
“Oh, right,” I said. “I know. He was so young.”
“So young,” she repeated.
“It’s funny how he seems so young for dying, but I’m his same age, and I feel like a fucking geriatric.”
Lindsey smiled but didn’t say anything.
“Are you seeing anybody?”
“Oh, I’m married,” she said. She must have felt me look at her hand. “I don’t wear my ring when I travel.”
“Across the Delaware River?”
The waitress brought us coffees without asking, which struck me as rude, and Lindsey asked for a food menu even though she’d said she wasn’t eating. She looked the same with limp, actinic-blonde hair, fried at the ends. She was trash-pretty despite her teeth, which were spaced apart, vampiric, like colonial turrets shooting from her gums. Her vagina in high school had an astringent taste, which I knew now to be the sure sign of a yeast infection.
I had not been with many girls since Lindsey, just here and there to impress men over the years, all of whom turned out to be on their own paths to the Lord. I felt Lindsey judging me, which felt backwards and strange.
Then she said, “Jesse’s coming.”
“Coming here?” I asked, jamming my finger into the table’s surface.
“No, the funeral.”
“I know, I saw him on the Facebook group.”
“Do you think it’ll be weird?” she asked.
“Maybe,” I said. “I hadn’t really thought about it.”
But I had really thought about it. Jesse was the reason I’d decided to attend at all. I thought maybe we would reconnect, laugh about old times in the Nova, get a little turned on in the process, smoke and chew gum at the same time. Have dinner that would turn into kissing, that would turn into aperitifs in one of our hotel rooms, where we would make radical love and stumble on epiphany: after all these years, we were meant to be together. I didn’t even have his number.
“Any kids?” I asked.
“No,” she said.
I nodded and looked down at the table. All those abortions must have taken their toll.
“Where’s your husband?”
“Home,” she said. “Working. He couldn’t make it.”
I was starting to wonder why Lindsey had asked me to join her. She didn’t seem the slightest bit interested in catching up.
“I asked you to be a bridesmaid in my wedding,” she said.
“Oh, you did? I’m sorry.” I vaguely recalled a message from her years earlier, which I had ignored.
The waitress set down Lindsey’s flaking spanakopita, which had been cut from a tray and had wilted spinach and feta slouching out of it. I’d wanted the grilled octopus, but for fear that Lindsey would insist on paying, I got sesame noodles with tahini dressing. It was served cold, but only in the way it was supposed to be.
“I never realized this was a Greek place,” I said.
“I didn’t have a lot of girlfriends to ask.”
“I’m really sorry, Lindsey,” I said. “I must’ve missed it. I must’ve been going through something.”
“Karl had eleven groomsmen and I only had three bridesmaids.”
“Eleven?”
“Anyway, no worries,” she said, looking away.
“I can’t even believe the shit we used to do in high school,” I said.
“Right, sure,” she said. “Are you talking about when we used to fuck Jesse together?”
“Yeah.”
“Uh-huh,” she said. “Are you going to try to bag him?”
“Bag him?”
“Yeah.”
“I hadn’t thought about it,” I said.
“Right, sure.”
I didn’t know what could cause a hemorrhagic stroke at thirty-nine, but I imagined it had something to do with Jerry’s blood pressure. He’d been on his way to pick up hydrochlorothiazide, a diuretic often prescribed to aid this. This kind of stroke occurs when a blood vessel ruptures and bleeds into the brain. It’s called a subarachnoid hemorrhage, which sounds complicated, but roughly translates to you’re fucking dead.
We walked through the front door of Thompson & White into a large parlor with beige chesterfield couches, drum chandeliers, framed obituaries, and a mahogany reception desk with a woman behind it. She directed us to an open door, a sign in front of which read WELCOME, LOVED ONES OF JERRY MORBIER. Beyond it stood the William Yardley High School class of 1994.
They were all dressed in sad, bad black. The women wore outdated patent leather heels from the back of their closets; the men wore ill-fitting suits and reeked of JCPenney cologne—bergamot, sandalwood.
Jesse leaned up against the partition, looking just as I remembered, with thick, brown hair and razor burn scattered on his chin and cheeks, holding a plastic cup of water. Elisa Matthews, (poorly-aged cheerleader), faced him, running her mouth, shooting her shot. She wore a sleeveless satin dress which showcased a Band-Aid on her bicep, and just above it, a nicotine patch. Dustin and Sara Dupont clung to each other by the refreshments table just as they had at senior prom, boasting their union, which had resulted in a homely set of invitro twins: Bippity and Boppity.
April Frank looked just as intimidating as she had in the ‘90s, just as slight, wearing charcoal wool and Asscher-cut diamonds through her lobes. Christina Stewart, with all her rage, ate a marshy wedge of green bean casserole off a Dixie plate in a red upholstered wing chair.
Off in the farthest part of the room was Jerry, embalmed under blue and red cosmetic bulbs, which aimed down at him like spotlights from the low, white ceiling.
“Should we pay our respects?” I asked Lindsey.
“You go ahead,” she said.
She inhaled, stalled, then walked over to Jesse at the partition, interrupting Elisa Matthews by giving him an inappropriate hug. I felt instantly betrayed, like our lunch had meant nothing to her.
Cheap sympathy bouquets of cream roses, white miniature carnations, purple statice, and pitta negra squatted in square, blue vases on either side of Jerry and the front row of chairs. Very softly, off a silver stereo system, Bon Jovi’s “Never Say Goodbye” played. I approached, stood over him, and studied the same bovine face that had sat across from me at Pancho’s Mexican Buffet, but was now so clearly dead, powdered and still. He wore high-waisted navy pants, black dress shoes, a white Life is Good shirt, and a black blazer. He’d gone prematurely gray and was at least seventy pounds overweight, laying in his fat almost like he was floating in a pool. I pretended to pray, faced the floor with my eyes closed, and listened to the hushed conversation between Dustin and Sara Dupont.
“She wanted to do it at their church in Kentucky,” said Sara.
“Why didn’t she?” asked Dustin.
“It was his wish to get buried in the cemetery behind the baseball diamond. His dad used to coach—yada yada.”
“Are his parents here?”
“We saw them, remember? In the parking lot, crying.”
“That was them?” asked Dustin. “Why didn’t they do it at Incarnation?”
Incarnation was a church in Ewing with blood-red carpets. I’d been there for two shotgun weddings.
Two TVs in either corner played a slideshow on a loop, beginning with a plumpish baby in a puffing diaper, childhood springs on the beam clay, blown-out Kentucky wedding photos in which Robyn wore a taffeta A-line gown and buried her face into the shoulders of Jerry and her father, respectively. Then came the stills of Jerry sitting next to her in chemo, her hair wispy and short while she gave two thumbs up, followed by a picture of him and the woman from church, walking together in a march for breast cancer research. The slideshow itself seemed to confirm the affair.
“Why’d Robyn invite her?” I heard Dustin ask Sara. “Just the right thing to do?”
“The Christian thing.”
“It’s not like she had any evidence,” he said.
“She doesn’t need any,” said Sara. “She’s a woman. Women know.”
Robyn Morbier came through the door in a hurry, like she’d been rushing around all day, trying to get everything right. She wore a black skirt suit with a white collared shirt, unintentionally matching the funeral home staff. I drifted over to Dustin and Sara, trying to include myself in their conversation.
“This is weird,” I said. “Feels like just yesterday he took me to that Mexican place.”
“Pancho’s?” asked Sara. “He took everyone to Pancho’s.”
“My God,” said Dustin. “How many girls was this guy fucking?”
My special memory deflated; I could still taste the Sprite. I could still hear his Taurus going over the hill. The humidity at Pancho’s made the stippled walls balmy with condensation. The floors had just been mopped, evidenced by a wet, yellow bucket, and both Jerry and I were being evidently careful, stepping in grace between the buffet and our table. The door smacked the wall as families came and went, and flimsy Dollar Tree strollers ricocheted off the feet of tables. A gay couple sat near us, holding hands, and Jerry said (through his teeth), “Nothing wrong with that.”
“Did the guy have a huge cock or something?”
“Dustin,” said Sara. “He’s dead.”
“So, he can’t have a huge cock?”
“Don’t say stuff like that. He’s dead,” she said. “Did you talk to my mom to see how the boys are doing?”
“When would I have talked to your mom?”
“I don’t know, when you went to the bathroom.”
“That’s great, Sara.”
I wandered over to Jesse and Lindsey, who had effectively ditched Elisa Matthews.
“Hey, Jesse,” I said.
“It’s so sad,” he said, and kissed my cheek.
Lindsey shot me a look. “Nice to have everybody together, though.”
“Where are you living?” Jesse asked me.
“Pittsburgh,” I said.
“Ewing,” said Lindsey.
“Oh, I go to Incarnation,” he said.
“Small world,” she said. “Do you wanna get a snack?”
Jesse shrugged agreeably, glancing at me first, and Lindsey pulled him toward the refreshments table, like she wanted to know what his deal was. She ran her hand down his suit jacket. She was thinner than me, sure, by a considerable margin, but I thought I was more attractive, or at least stood a chance. Of course, it took me years to figure out that this simply doesn’t mean much.
It was the first open casket funeral I’d been to since I was a child, when Nanny, my paternal grandma, lay in a pink cashmere sweater and my father wept over her incessantly, which in turn, made me cry. My mother carried me out and sat with me in the car where she kept a light green flask, escaping our spotless Greek relatives, and we played a few rounds of Old Maid.
I wandered over toward Robyn and said, “Robyn, I’m so sorry.”
She nodded stiffly, then her face crumpled into a stifled series of cries. She turned and went back out the door where her mother stood next to the guestbook, and I was alone again.
I approached the refreshments table and overheard April Frank in a concerned conversation with Dustin and Sara.
“There’s no Eucharist!” said April.
“There’s not a built-in chapel at this home,” said Sara.
“Why didn’t they do it at the funeral home on Delaware Avenue? They have a chapel,” said Dustin.
“That chapel is for Asians,” said Sara.
“What do you mean it’s for Asians?” asked April.
“Hindu, Vietnamese, Laotian, Cambodian, Korean, Chinese, you name it. They do, like, Buddhist services. I’ve seen the monks going in and out.”
“At least they have a priest attending,” said April.
As if announced, the priest faltered in, wearing abnormally thick, black shoes, like something was wrong with his feet. He was fat and bald, wearing an alb of white linen, and I heard Elisa Matthews and Christina Stewart whispering by the casserole.
“They got a priest?”
“Robyn’s mother,” said Christina, as if this were an answer.
“Why didn’t they do it at the church across the street?” asked Elisa.
“Booked out.”
“Booked out?”
“Far out.”
“Have you heard anything about the student driver he hit?” asked Elisa.
“Pretty sure he just took out a headlight.”
“No one’s in a coma?”
“Where’d you hear that?” asked Christina.
Then came the woman from Robyn and Jerry’s church group, whose name I came to know was Kathy Baumann. She had a blue airbrushed memorial T-shirt tucked into a black ruched skirt and matching ballet flats with a large, clear gemstone at the toe. She was dark-haired, frizzy, and her curves sprawled at the hip as if to suggest, no matter her age, that she was spilling with eggs.
“That’s her,” Christina whispered to Elisa.
“That’s her?”
“Kathy fucking Baumann,” I heard Sara say to Dustin.
As she walked by, the scent of lavender and tiger lily couldn’t hide the stench of gin. She was crying, which turned to sobbing upon seeing her dear, dead Jerry, with his head on the sterile coffin pillow and his mouth sewn shut from the jaw.
“I can smell his aftershave!” she cried, bending over a chair with a hopeless, quaking back.
Nobody went to help her for fear that Robyn would see; it was an unspoken understanding to pretend that Kathy Baumann was not there, had never known Jerry Morbier, or been involved with him in any way. Everybody looked elsewhere, choosing a direction or an object in the room, and fixing on it with great intent while this woman sobbed and sobbed. Everyone went silent, even Dustin and Sara, who were no strangers to tantrums thanks to Bippity and Boppity.
Jesse came out of nowhere, pulled me out to the front parlor, and began to kiss my neck and feel up my ribs to my chest.
“God, I missed this,” he said, and I didn’t stop him.
“Where’s Lindsey?” I asked.
“She’s gonna wait for us at my hotel.”
I said, “I was gonna stay a little longer.”
“Why? This is a fucking shit show,” he said. “Aren’t I what you came here for?”
The woman at the front desk watched us in her peripheral; I could feel Robyn’s mother’s stare on the backs of my shoulder blades. It was all so wildly rude and inappropriate that the humiliation struck my cheeks, running hot and red.
“I knew Jerry,” I said. “We used to go out.”
“Jesus, his hands were full,” said Jesse.
Over the insanity of this moment I had longed for, I heard Kathy Baumann weeping. I shook my head. Jesse took out his wallet and handed me his hotel key.
“When you’re ready,” he said, “it’s the Marriott in Willow Grove, room three-twelve.”
He left without saying goodbye to anyone, making it clear that he’d only come for another go with me and Lindsey. I didn’t want too much time to pass for them to realize they didn’t need me to get started, but I followed the cries of Kathy Baumann back into the room.
Now everyone was sitting, and the priest had tripped multiple times—over the legs of chairs, cords, his own shoes—each time garnering a dull gasp from his audience. He appeared to be concussed or mentally declining, as he delivered a muddled eulogy about his own late mother. Robyn and her mother leaned into the same hip and held the same hand to their forehead. It could have been a picture. They sat down the same way, as though they’d reached an ultimate exhaustion. The slideshow started back from the beginning. There was Jerry in his diaper. There was his mistress weeping loudly.
“She loved life and she loved us. God loves her,” the priest said for his mother. “At this time, I’d like to invite anyone who’d like to say a few words about the deceased.”
“I don’t think that was part of the package we selected,” said Robyn’s mother.
Then she stood up: Kathy fucking Baumann. Everyone looked at each other as she approached the lectern and motioned to the stereo.
“Can someone please turn that down?”
Dustin, who was closest, looked at Robyn then obliged, turning down Tracy Chapman’s “Fast Car” so the room fell silent, staring at Kathy and the slideshow of Jerry’s wedding looping on either side of her. Robyn’s mother looked on with on-fire disdain.
“Jerry Morbier was a very special man,” Kathy fought to say. “He was my rock. He was the best thing that ever happened to me. And I know what you’re all thinking, but he was just a beautiful person.” She stepped down and walked back toward her seat, then turned to the priest and said, “And I’m sorry about your mama.”
She sat down with a huff, and then the cries came back, as if attacking her. Robyn stood up and everyone watched, like she was going to kill Kathy, and she approached her seat. Kathy didn’t look up, and Robyn sat down beside her, and they wept together for this man they’d both lost.
I remembered him at Pancho’s, telling me about his likes and dislikes. I tried hard to recall them then. It was peculiar to remember Jerry, a dead person, eating. What he had long done to sustain himself, to keep himself alive, he would never do again. We’d never kissed. We’d never had sex. I had this big, beautiful ass and he never got to see it. It was a tragedy.
The priest had made his way over to the refreshments table and was struggling to lift a wedge of green bean casserole onto a plate. He messed up the whole casserole in the process 22and, under his breath, whispered, “Oh, dear Lord. Oh, mother. Oh, dear Lord.”
His oldness made me think of my parents in their Naples condo: my mother sprawling on the hot pink couch, surrounded by stupefying plants, which she kept more alive than herself. My father sinking into his worn leather chair, and on his lap, their stinking yorkie, Melanie, whose eyes were always wet; she relieved herself on the artificial turf at the bottom of the building, never happier.
I looked over at Christina Stewart and we met eyes; she raised her brows at me as if to say, “Can you believe this?” and it was like years of friendship were restored. Suddenly, everything was fine; she had never walked in on me using her hairbrush on myself in our dorm room, and we could go back to talking about the bodies of boys and taking flash photos in restaurants. Then she leaned over to April Frank and whispered something, April looked at me, and they both looked away. Everything was lost.
The priest had gotten the casserole onto his plate and was now struggling with his fork, trying to get a good bite with a bit of everything on it. Robyn and Kathy were now holding each other, sorrowing into each other’s outfits. Kathy’s memorial T-shirt stained quickly with Robyn’s sensible brown mascara. The slideshow started over from the beginning.
I went to Jesse’s hotel room and opened the door, expecting to find them already engaged in the act. He and Lindsey were on the bed facing each other, fully clothed. The room was nice in a uniform way with a white king bed and a big TV. An empty bottle of Prosecco sat on its hip in a metal bucket on the dresser. The blue carpet was soft, almost kind, on the bottoms of my feet, which ached from my pinching, black shoes.
The dark gray track curtains had been pulled over the windows. A blue barrel chair with a white diamond pattern sat off to the side with its matching ottoman. The air conditioner whirred; in fact, the room was freezing, and as if my expression gave it away, Lindsey said, “We can’t turn it off.” A wooden desk with a leather chair was in another corner, and this was where Jesse had set down his belongings: an open blue duffel bag and his suit jacket, slumping.
I sat down on the bed and Jesse reached for one of my legs, stroking it with his thumb, and leaned in to kiss me. This was enough to prompt Lindsey to take off her dress, and she lay up against the headboard, running her middle finger up and down her labia. Jesse pulled my dress over my head and turned me to face Lindsey on my knees, so my head was between her legs.
He inhaled sharply and said, “There’s a pool.”
Lindsey’s skin was pale in a way I hadn’t remembered, and sebum dispersed across it, forming pimples all over. This was true even about her ass and inner thighs. I hovered over her; Jesse spanked me, and it was quiet, but it hurt, and Lindsey said, “Spank her again,” and I said, “Harder,” and before penetrating either of us, Jesse finished all over the Marriott duvet.
“No!”
“It’s okay,” we said in unison, turning blankly into mothers.
Jesse stormed off to the bathroom and I went to stand up, but Lindsey pulled me back, saying, “Wait.”
My head pressed into the bone of her sternum and her hand rested weakly on my ass. I watched her brown nipple soften, fading into the fat of her mammary. I wished my eyes could close around her body so we could be in the darkness together. I could hear Jesse in the bathroom, pissing. His semen on the duvet could have been interchangeable with Pancho’s mole blanco, which, from its little plastic cup on Jerry’s tray, had smelled of sunflower and pine nuts. I had the sensation of wanting to tell Lindsey that I loved her, but held the words inside me, bleating, knocking ferociously from the inside of my mouth.
Jesse came out of the bathroom and jerked the track curtains open, as if to announce the end of the interaction. Lindsey pushed her nose into my hair. Through the windows, from the bed, I could just make out the beginnings of the parking lot, half-full of cars and lined by hemlocks and dogwoods.
Carolynn Mireault is a Leslie Epstein Fellow, Global Fellow, and the Senior Teaching Fellow in the MFA program at Boston University. She is a recipient of the 2022 St. Botolph Club Foundation Emerging Artist Award in Literature and the 2022 Florence Engel Randall Fiction Award. Her work has recently appeared or is forthcoming in Cutleaf, Louisiana Literature, BULL, Glassworks Magazine, the Westchester Review, Abandon Journal, and FEED among others.